
Declaring ownership non-existent: when someone else's entry in the Unified State Register of Real Estate can be removed
26 October 2026Author
Andrey MorozovPractices
Introduction
An entry in the Unified State Register of Real Estate (the "Register") does not always reflect reality. The right to the same property may be registered to different persons. A separate right may be registered to a technical room that by law belongs to the owners of premises in an apartment building. In such cases, a claim for a declaration that the right of ownership is non-existent is used.
Purpose of the claim
It makes it possible to challenge someone else's registered right where the claimant's infringed right cannot be protected by recognising the claimant's own right or by recovering the property from another person's unlawful possession. The mechanism is described in Joint Plenum Resolution No. 10 of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation and No. 22 of the Supreme Commercial Court of the Russian Federation of 29 April 2010 "On certain issues arising in court practice when resolving disputes related to the protection of the right of ownership and other rights in rem", as amended on 12 December 2023 (the "Resolution No. 10/22").
The claim is exceptional in nature. The claimant must explain why other remedies do not restore their right (paragraph 52 of Resolution No. 10/22).
The court's decision becomes the basis for entering a record in the Register that the defendant's right has terminated. It does not replace the return of property or the removal of physical obstacles to its use (paragraphs 52–53 of Resolution No. 10/22).
Grounds for going to court
A claim for a declaration that the right of ownership is non-existent can be brought in cases of:
- Double registration. The right to the same property is registered to different persons.
- Registration of an object that is not real estate. The Supreme Court held that a sports ground in the form of paving was part of a land plot rather than a separate object, despite its registration (Ruling of the Judicial Chamber for Economic Disputes of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 7 April 2016 No. 310-ES15-16638, case No. A35-8277/2014).
- Termination of an encumbrance, such as a mortgage that remains in the Register (paragraph 52 of Resolution No. 10/22).
- The object ceasing to exist while the entry remains. A claim is possible if the entry infringes the rights of an interested person and there are no other remedies (Ruling of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 18 September 2018 No. 303-ES18-13551, case No. A51-10310/2017).
- Private ownership arising over common property of an apartment building. The Supreme Court allowed such a claim in a dispute over a technical basement that served the building, had no independent purpose and had never left the possession of the owners (Ruling of the Judicial Chamber for Economic Disputes of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 25 July 2025 No. 305-ES25-2385, case No. A40-88564/2023; the "Ruling of 25 July 2025").
The claim should not substitute for specific remedies:
- If the property needs to be returned, consider a vindication claim;
- If the dispute concerns the boundaries of a plot, resolve the boundary issue itself;
- For unauthorised construction, the choice of claim depends on the characteristics of the object and the grounds for applying Article 222 of the Civil Code, and registration alone is not enough to rule out demolition (paragraph 52 of Resolution No. 10/22; Ruling of the Judicial Chamber for Economic Disputes of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 17 February 2015 No. 303-ES14-3451, case No. A51-27083/2013; Resolution of the Presidium of the Supreme Commercial Court of the Russian Federation of 24 January 2012 No. 12576/11, case No. A46-14110/2010).
An entry in the Register does not in itself determine the remedy. One needs to understand whether removing the defendant's right is enough to restore the claimant's right, or whether a different dispute must be resolved: over the return of property, the boundaries of a plot or the fate of a building.
Parties to the dispute
In disputes of this kind, the following points about the parties are important:
- The claimant must show which of their rights is infringed by the registration and how granting the claim will restore it. Mere disagreement with the entry is not enough (paragraph 52 of Resolution No. 10/22).
- Where there are competing rights to the same property, the claim may be brought by the owner in possession against a person who does not possess the property but is listed as the right holder. It is therefore important to establish who actually possesses the property (Ruling of the Judicial Chamber for Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 8 August 2017 in case No. 5-KG17-115; the "Ruling of 8 August 2017").
- In a dispute over the common property of an apartment building, a single owner of a unit may go to court. The consent of the other owners is not required (Ruling of 25 July 2025).
- The defendant is the person to whom the disputed right is registered. Rosreestr is not a proper defendant but may participate as a third party. The court's judgment is binding on the registrar regardless of its participation in the case (paragraph 53 of Resolution No. 10/22).
- A dispute with the right holder cannot be replaced by challenging registration actions: a dispute over a right to real estate is not resolved in that way (paragraph 56 of Resolution No. 10/22).
Facts to be proven
What must be proven depends on the grounds of the claim. The claimant needs to establish:
- The existence of the disputed entry and the characteristics of the property;
- Their own right, infringed by the entry remaining in place;
- Circumstances that rule out the defendant's right continuing to exist;
- Actual possession of the property, if the choice of remedy depends on it;
- That granting the claim will restore the right.
The claimant must prove the grounds for the absence of the defendant's right. The defendant cannot be required to confirm the accuracy of the Register and the entire chain of transfer of the right to them (Ruling of 8 August 2017). Registration is confirmed by Register data; other evidence is selected according to the nature of the dispute (paragraph 54 of Resolution No. 10/22).
In disputes over the common property of an apartment building, the original purpose of the premises, their technical characteristics, their service function and the impossibility of independent use are important. Registration of a separate right does not cancel the regime of common ownership arising by law, but the building-wide purpose must be proven (Article 290 of the Civil Code, Article 36(1) of the Housing Code; Ruling of 25 July 2025).
In the case decided by the Ruling of 25 July 2025, an expert examination established the presence of utility systems serving several units, the ancillary function of the property and its unsuitability for independent use other than for building-wide needs. The court held that there was no need to recognise the existing right of common ownership again: the infringement was remedied by declaring the city's right non-existent. In a similar dispute, it is therefore worth studying the technical documentation, actual use and access arrangements, and, if necessary, putting technical questions to an expert. The legal classification of the property is a matter for the court.
Limitation period
The name of the claim does not exclude the limitation period. The general limitation period applies to challenging a registered right (Article 196 of the Civil Code). Entry of a record in the Register does not in itself mean that the claimant learned or should have learned of the infringement on that day (paragraph 57 of Resolution No. 10/22). If an inaccurate entry infringes the claimant's right without depriving them of possession, then, by analogy with a negatory claim, no limitation period applies (Article 208, paragraph 5 of the Civil Code; paragraph 57 of Resolution No. 10/22). In the Ruling of 25 July 2025, the decisive factor was the continuous use of the disputed property to service the building's utilities: the premises had never left the owners' possession, and the limitation objection was rejected.
Whether the property belongs to the common property and whether possession has been retained should therefore be examined separately. For example, where a driveway has been fenced off, it is important to establish who controls access and whether it is still possible to use the property.
C Cases recommendations
- Define the outcome. Before going to court, decide whether it is enough to remove someone else's right or whether you also need to recover the property, remove a fence or restore access. The remedy and the content of the claims depend on this.
- Gather documents. Check the Register data and the grounds for registering the defendant's right, and prepare documents on the purpose and characteristics of the property.
- Confirm possession. Establish how the property is actually used and collect evidence of possession: it matters both for the choice of claim and for the limitation issue.
- Assess the need for an expert examination. If the dispute concerns the technical characteristics of the property, decide whether an expert examination is needed.
If someone else's registered right infringes your interests, or a claim has been brought against you to declare your right of ownership non-existent, the C Cases team is ready to analyse the grounds for registration and the use of the property, determine the proper remedy, build the evidence base and represent your interests in court.
Sources
- Civil Code of the Russian Federation (Part One) No. 51-FZ of 30 November 1994;
- Housing Code of the Russian Federation No. 188-FZ of 29 December 2004;
- Joint Plenum Resolution No. 10 of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation and No. 22 of the Supreme Commercial Court of the Russian Federation of 29 April 2010 "On certain issues arising in court practice when resolving disputes related to the protection of the right of ownership and other rights in rem" (as amended on 12 December 2023);
- Resolution of the Presidium of the Supreme Commercial Court of the Russian Federation of 24 January 2012 No. 12576/11;
- Ruling of the Judicial Chamber for Economic Disputes of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 17 February 2015 No. 303-ES14-3451;
- Ruling of the Judicial Chamber for Economic Disputes of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 7 April 2016 No. 310-ES15-16638;
- Ruling of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 8 August 2017 No. 5-KG17-115;
- Ruling of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 18 September 2018 No. 303-ES18-13551;
- Ruling of the Judicial Chamber for Economic Disputes of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 25 July 2025 No. 305-ES25-2385.