When entering into a contract, it is important to define not only the parties' obligations but also how financial risks are allocated. Additional costs may arise without any breach of contract — for example, as a result of demands from public authorities or third parties.

For such cases, the parties may provide for indemnity for property losses in their contract. This mechanism was introduced into Russian law in 2015, inspired by the Anglo-American concept of "indemnity". It allows a party to accept a particular risk when entering into a transaction while securing compensation should that risk materialise.

However, applying the mechanism still causes difficulties: it is often confused with damages, and contract terms do not always make it possible to determine clearly the grounds for and amount of compensation. Whether compensation can actually be obtained therefore depends largely on how precisely the parties have worded their agreement. In this article, we look at when this mechanism can be useful and what to bear in mind when using it.

What is indemnity for property losses?

Contracting parties are used to situations such as a supplier delivering goods late or a contractor missing a deadline. In such cases, the related costs can be recovered as damages. The basis for such a claim is a breach of obligation.

Indemnity for property losses applies in a different situation: the obligation to pay compensation arises not from a breach of contract but upon the occurrence of a circumstance agreed by the parties (Article 406.1 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation). That circumstance must be connected with the subject matter of the contract, its performance, amendment or termination.

For example, during the purchase of a stake in a company, an unresolved dispute with a former landlord is discovered. The buyer is prepared to close the deal but does not intend to bear the financial consequences of that dispute. The parties may agree that, if the debt is recovered from the company, the seller will compensate the buyer for the related losses. The method of calculating those losses must be set out separately: the company's debt is not in itself equal to the losses of its participant.

What should the contract provide for?

For the mechanism to apply, the parties must agree on:

  1. The trigger for payment, i.e. the specific circumstance upon which the obligation to compensate losses arises.
    IMPORTANT! This event must be clearly defined; vague wording (for example, "the occurrence of any adverse consequences") will not protect the party seeking indemnity later on.
  2. The scope of losses, i.e. the specific losses to be compensated and the contracting party to whom compensation is paid.
  3. The amount of compensation or the method of determining it.

The party seeking indemnity must prove:

  • that the circumstance provided for in the contract has occurred;
  • that losses have been incurred or will inevitably be incurred in the future;
  • a causal link between that circumstance and the losses.

Who can use this mechanism?

As a general rule, the parties may agree on indemnity for property losses if they are acting in the course of business.

An exception applies to shareholders' agreements and agreements for the disposal of shares or participatory interests in a company's charter capital. In these, an indemnity clause is also permitted where individuals without sole proprietor status are parties (Article 406.1(5) of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation).

Possible risks

1. Inability to obtain compensation because the indemnity clause is uncertain

General wording (for example, "the seller shall compensate all possible losses of the buyer") does not make it possible to determine clearly the grounds for payment, the scope of losses to be compensated or the method of calculating compensation.

The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation has clarified that an indemnity agreement must be express and unambiguous (paragraph 17 of Plenum Resolution of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 7 of 24 March 2016 "On the application by courts of certain provisions of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation on liability for breach of obligations"). If it cannot be established from the clause whether the parties agreed on indemnity for losses or on liability for breach of obligation, the mechanism does not apply.

2. Inability to obtain compensation because the grounds for payment are not proven

The existence of a contractual clause does not in itself guarantee recovery. The party seeking indemnity must prove the occurrence of the circumstance provided for in the contract, the existence or inevitability of losses and a causal link between that circumstance and the losses.

3. Refusal of indemnity in case of bad faith

If the party seeking compensation contributed in bad faith to the occurrence of the circumstance for which indemnity is provided, that circumstance is deemed not to have occurred. As a result, no right to compensation arises on that ground. For example, a landlord undertakes to reimburse a tenant's costs of fitting out the premises if the tenant fails to obtain a permit to operate. The tenant decides to abandon the project and deliberately fails to submit the required documents in order to be refused and claim compensation. In that case, the tenant cannot obtain indemnity.

Conclusion

Indemnity for property losses means a deal need not be abandoned merely because it carries a known but not yet materialised financial risk. Instead, the parties determine in advance who will bear its consequences and how compensation will be calculated.

However, the mechanism does not work automatically. Its effectiveness depends on the precision of the agreement: what event must occur, whose losses are covered and how the amount of payment is determined.

C Cases recommendations

When preparing a contract, the C Cases team recommends:

  1. Identify the specific risks of the transaction.
    For example, when buying a business, these may include disputes, claims relating to past periods and other circumstances discovered during due diligence.
  2. Distinguish losses from liability for breach.
    If the payment relates to delay, failure to perform an obligation or inaccurate information provided, the appropriate legal mechanism must be determined separately.
  3. Describe the trigger for payment in detail.
    Specify the particular dispute, period, claim or other circumstance, as well as the moment when the right to compensation arises.
  4. Agree on how compensation is calculated and capped.
    We recommend determining which amounts are included in the indemnity, whether losses are covered in full or in part, and whether there is a maximum payment. The formula should make it possible to calculate the amount, rather than require new negotiations once the problem arises.
  5. Set out the procedure for making claims.
    We recommend agreeing in advance on how the other party is to be notified, how documents are to be provided and how disagreements are to be resolved.

If you are entering into a contract and want to determine in advance who will bear the costs should disputed circumstances arise, or you are already facing an indemnity claim, the C Cases team can help assess the situation, draft the contractual terms and build a position for negotiations or litigation.

Sources

  1. Civil Code of the Russian Federation (Part One) No. 51-FZ of 30 November 1994;
  2. Plenum Resolution of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 7 of 24 March 2016 "On the application by courts of certain provisions of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation on liability for breach of obligations".

Need advice?

Describe your situation — we will reply within one business day.

Request a consultation